Columbus Crew vs New York City FC

1 - 2
🕒 Thu, 23 Jul 2026 00:30 Europe/London 📍 Lower.com Field 🧑‍⚖️ L. Hernandez 🔁 Regular Season - 16 🏁 match finished
Season
2026-2027 Season
Stage
Regular Season - 16
Regular Season Table
Columbus Crew 27 · New York City FC 15
Referee Stats
12 matches · 3.67 yellow cards avg
Yellow cards avg 3.67
Reds avg 0.17
Penalties avg 0.42
Over 4.5 cards 33%
Home wins 42%
Draws 33%
Away wins 25%
How the match was won
  • Physical contest: 5 yellows.

Team Overview

Columbus Crew (Home stats)

Games / Record

13
W-D-L: 5-2-6

Goals For / Against

17 / 15
Avg: 1.31 / 1.15

Points

17
Avg: 1.31

Clean Sheets

4

Failed to Score

3
New York City FC (Away stats)

Games / Record

12
W-D-L: 4-4-4

Goals For / Against

13 / 13
Avg: 1.08 / 1.08

Points

16
Avg: 1.33

Clean Sheets

2

Failed to Score

2

Match Context & Trends

Venue-only form, goal timing, first-goal trends and league context around this MLS fixture.

Quick comparison bars

1.31
PPG
1.33
1.31
GF
1.08
1.15
GA
1.08
54%
O2.5
33%
54%
BTTS
67%
46%
Score 1st
42%

League-position context

Columbus Crew rank27th
New York City FC rank15th
Columbus Crew points23
New York City FC points32
Columbus Crew: #27 · 23 pts · GD -7
23 pts off the top 2. 18 pts off the play-off line. 5 pts from safety.
New York City FC: #15 · 32 pts · GD +6
14 pts off the top 2. 9 pts off the play-off line. 9 pts clear of the relegation zone.
9-point gap between the two sides coming into kick-off.

Columbus Crew last 5 home

L W L L W
Points6/15
Weighted index33
Goals7-7
Record2-0-3
Weighted index gives more importance to the most recent venue-specific matches. 100 means maximum recent points return.
Recent venue-specific form has been unstable.

New York City FC last 5 away

W D D L W
Points8/15
Weighted index56
Goals7-5
Record2-2-1
Weighted index gives more importance to the most recent venue-specific matches. 100 means maximum recent points return.
Recent venue-specific form is balanced.

Columbus Crew trend breakdown

Over 2.554%
BTTS54%
BTTS + O2.546%
1H Over 0.577%
Also: Over 0.5 92% · Over 1.5 77% · Over 3.5 15% · 1H BTTS 23%

New York City FC trend breakdown

Over 2.533%
BTTS67%
BTTS + O2.533%
1H Over 0.5100%
Also: Over 0.5 100% · Over 1.5 83% · Over 3.5 0% · 1H BTTS 25%

Scoring reliability

Columbus Crew score at home77%
Columbus Crew clean sheet at home31%
New York City FC score away83%
New York City FC clean sheet away17%

First-goal patterns

Columbus Crew score first46%
Columbus Crew win after scoring first50%
New York City FC score first42%
New York City FC win after scoring first80%
Comeback rate after conceding first: Columbus Crew 40% · New York City FC 33%
Avg first goal minute: Columbus Crew 20.8' · New York City FC 28.4'

Vs league average

Columbus Crew score at home1.31 vs 1.83
Columbus Crew concede at home1.15 vs 1.37
New York City FC score away1.08 vs 1.37
New York City FC concede away1.08 vs 1.83
Columbus Crew score 28% below league average, while New York City FC score 21% below league average.
Defensive side: Columbus Crew are 16% below league average at home, and New York City FC are 41% below league average away.

Head-to-head trends

Recent games5
Avg goals3.40
BTTS60%
Over 2.580%
At this venue setup: 3.20 goals on average across the last 5.

Columbus Crew goal timing (home)

1H scored: 53% 2H scored: 47% Danger: 76-90+ Vulnerable: 76-90+
Goals scored by 15-minute interval
76-90+ 5
31-45 4
0-15 2
16-30 2
46-60 2
61-75 0
Goals conceded by 15-minute interval
76-90+ 5
61-75 4
0-15 3
31-45 3
16-30 2
46-60 1

New York City FC goal timing (away)

1H scored: 54% 2H scored: 46% Danger: 16-30 Vulnerable: 76-90+
Goals scored by 15-minute interval
16-30 4
61-75 4
31-45 2
0-15 1
46-60 1
76-90+ 1
Goals conceded by 15-minute interval
76-90+ 5
0-15 2
16-30 2
31-45 2
61-75 2
46-60 1

Match Statistics

Shots on Goal
Total Shots
Shots off Goal
Blocked Shots
Shots Inside Box
Shots Outside Box
Ball Possession
Corner Kicks
Fouls
Offsides
Yellow Cards
Red Cards
Goalkeeper Saves
Total Passes
Passes Accurate
Passes %

Events

Yellow Cards
Home
3
Away
2
Red Cards
Home
0
Away
0
Substitutions
Home
5
Away
4
28'
28' Goal · 0-1
N. Fernández Mercau
Penalty
40'
40' T. Gray
55'
55' B. Traoré
1st substitution · For: H. Wolf
55'
55' M. Jones
2nd substitution · For: Talles Magno
57'
57' J. Thiaré
60'
60' M. Arfsten
63'
63' T. Karumanchi
1st substitution · For: H. Picard
64'
64' M. Amundsen
2nd substitution · For: S. Moreira
70'
70' Goal · 0-2
A. Ojeda
Normal Goal · Assist: Talles Magno
74'
74' S. Bangoura
3rd substitution · For: D. Chambost
75'
75' J. Thiaré
4th substitution · For: D. Gazdag
77'
77' J. Shore
3rd substitution · For: K. Pierre
82'
82' T. Habroune
83'
83' N. Axundzadə
5th substitution · For: C. Adams
83'
83' Nico Cavallo
4th substitution · For: M. Carrizo
90'
90' VAR
Chase Adams
Penalty confirmed
90'
90' Goal · 1-2
D. Gazdag
Penalty
90+5'
90+5' J. Sands

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC 1-2: match report, goals, cards and substitutions

New York City FC beat Columbus Crew 2-1 on Thursday, 23 July 2026 in MLS. The match was refereed by L. Hernandez. It was played at Lower.com Field.

First half: New York City FC took the lead at 28' when N. Fernández Mercau scored (Penalty), making the score 0-1. T. Gray received a yellow card for New York City FC at 40'.

Second half: New York City FC made their 1st substitution at 55', with B. Traoré replacing H. Wolf. New York City FC made their 2nd substitution at 55', with M. Jones replacing Talles Magno. J. Thiaré received a yellow card for Columbus Crew at 57'. M. Arfsten received a yellow card for Columbus Crew at 60'. Columbus Crew made their 1st substitution at 63', with T. Karumanchi replacing H. Picard. Columbus Crew made their 2nd substitution at 64', with M. Amundsen replacing S. Moreira. New York City FC extended the lead at 70' when A. Ojeda scored, with the assist credited to Talles Magno, making the score 0-2. Columbus Crew made their 3rd substitution at 74', with S. Bangoura replacing D. Chambost. Columbus Crew made their 4th substitution at 75', with J. Thiaré replacing D. Gazdag. New York City FC made their 3rd substitution at 77', with J. Shore replacing K. Pierre. T. Habroune received a yellow card for Columbus Crew at 82'. Columbus Crew made their 5th substitution at 83', with N. Axundzadə replacing C. Adams. New York City FC made their 4th substitution at 83', with Nico Cavallo replacing M. Carrizo. VAR intervened at 90' for Columbus Crew (Penalty confirmed). Columbus Crew scored late to reduce the deficit at 90' when D. Gazdag scored (Penalty), making the score 1-2. J. Sands received a yellow card for New York City FC at 90+5'.

Columbus Crew used 5 substitutions while New York City FC used 4 substitutions. Columbus Crew got 3 yellow cards, while New York City FC got 2 yellow cards.

How the match was won

  • Physical contest: 5 yellows.

Head-to-Head Overview

All Meetings (Any Venue)
Total Games20
Home Wins8
Draws4
Away Wins8
Over 2.5 Goals12 (60.0%)
BTTS13 (65.0%)
Home vs Away as Scheduled
Total Games10
Home Wins6
Draws3
Away Wins1
Over 2.5 Goals7 (70.0%)
BTTS8 (80.0%)

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC Head-to-Head History by Season